The officially official Devuan Forum!

You are not logged in.

#26 Re: Devuan Derivatives » [...] Spaced Linux 10.26.2 » 2026-10-14 07:49:05

From the locked thread:

"..this is a desktop OS for normies.  Not for us hardened sysadmins..."

Why are you working on and marketing a derivative to make it "easier" for Joe Average?

What's in it for you?

#27 Re: Desktop and Multimedia » [SOLVED] Devuan 7, regarding KDE Plasma 6.7.6 and SonicDE » 2026-10-14 07:32:37

It couldn't be clearer.

The common mistake is to leave installation media connected / in the drive and reboot back into the installer again. If someone finds this confusing, then they probably shouldn't be installing an OS - but adversely if you got that far, then you must be doing ok...

#29 Re: Desktop and Multimedia » [SOLVED] Devuan 7, regarding KDE Plasma 6.7.6 and SonicDE » 2026-10-13 21:39:03

Gone are my opportunities to enjoy cordial, collegial, ephemeral discussions at a desk, in a conference room, or over lunch - face to face.

That would be "retirement"...

Until next time...

#30 Re: Intergalactic Communities » Spaced Linux » 2026-10-13 21:36:11

Oppressive moderation wearin' ya down?

Then git yer ass over to the independent alternative Devuan forum!

What ya waitin' fer!?

*fires a few shots and rides off*

(Disclaimer: I am in no way affiliated with the independent alternative unofficial Devuan forum which isn't a Devuan forum, despite having "devuan" in the domain name).

#31 Re: Desktop and Multimedia » [SOLVED] Nvidia drivers with security issues - what solutions for Devuan 6? » 2026-10-13 08:17:16

90 vulnerabilities listed...

Unfortunately, the old advice still stands. As Debian "freeze" the stable release, the Nvidia proprietary driver will most likely remain at that version. So the usual course of action is to install from the Nvidia shellscript (and reinstall from that after every kernel update). As it's a proprietary driver, no backporting of any security fixes is possible.

I have always taken the view that Debian simply should not have packaged these from day one, as this is old ground we have been going over for the last 20+ years.

The Debian wiki article discourages Nvidia hardware and also highlights the "planned obsolescence" aspects - but this is also relevant to AMD and Intel, which it appears to endorse.

#32 Re: Desktop and Multimedia » [SOLVED] Devuan 7, regarding KDE Plasma 6.7.6 and SonicDE » 2026-10-09 07:39:04

@rbit, #10 is a lot of babble, nonsense and ill informed opining. Not even worth your time.

#33 Re: Installation » Adhoc Test Plan for Installation ISOs » 2026-10-09 07:32:43

I'm not sure they're generated, I would say that's just their posting style. I found some activity via a web search elsewhere from 3 years ago and much the same style. Or perhap they ran their post through some LLM to come up with some of the wording in question.

There used to be someone at LQ who used a lot of text formatting and upper case. Made the posts at worst practically unreadable, at best obnoxious and preachy.

Aside from that, there's obviously far too much misdirected effort. It seems like the usual "$DISTRO is too difficult for beginners to install" thing.

#34 Re: Off-topic » bigLLM owes a big thanks to FSF. And FSF owes thanks to bigLLM ? » 2026-10-08 07:53:53

"...this toxic blight covers the entirety of the Internet. These companies are the absolute worst f****** parasites our society has yet created..."

- the developer of xscreensaver, former Netscape developer and Mozilla founder.

There is a clear strategy of plaigarism among these big LLMs. For those of us who are not the morons on the "it's a great tool!" bandwagon, it's all too obvious.

It's also just a small part of a wider corporate strategy to undermine and destroy FOSS software - in particular that which is licensed under the GPL. If you can get an LLM to "assist" in rewriting some GPL software, then release it under e.g. the MIT licence - profit. There will be enough corporate schills promoting and supporting the "fork", to ensure the obsolescence of the original. Any copyright issues can be sidestepped by rewriting in a fashionable "memory safe" language. Which also adds some much needed security theatre.

#35 Re: Desktop and Multimedia » What DE do you prefer to use on Devuan? » 2026-10-07 17:35:51

Regarding gnome-shell, A few months ago I set up an "off the shelf" Debian box with gnome as part of a work project.  Last time I tried it out was probably ten years ago? Itt wasn't at all great then, but it's quite frankly astonishing at how much it has regessed. It used to based around the "don't give the user too many options" philosophy. Now it's more like: "make certain the user can't do anything".

I can't see how anyone would find that usable or useful. I can't envisage who it's designed for or what use case.

I dislike automobile analogies, but it's akin to designing a car without an engine, or controls - as that's far safer and reduces obviously support overhead.

"The idiots can only do what we allow them"

Thus, your theoretical tech support only have to deal with problems 1 to 10.

The usual answers to 1 to 10 will be "reinstall".

#36 Re: Hardware & System Configuration » (HowTo) repair wrong permission-set? » 2026-10-05 17:33:37

The bad news is you broke it  - the good news is you get to keep all the pieces...

Lesson learnt on "AI"?

#37 Re: Other Issues » KDE Plasma freezes and becomes unresponsive sometimes » 2026-10-05 16:56:07

This could be the result of a GPU hang. When it occurs, it's a good iidea to see if you can bring up the first VT using CTRL+ALT+F1.  The error message may appear there, or go to the next one, log in as root and examine dmesg output.

It's interesting that a newer kernel solved it, and that points to a GPU driver related hang or similar.

Plasma is more demanding than some smaller window manager and makes use of the GPU for acceleration and desktop composition.

Unfortunately Debian and Devuan follow enterprise focused LTS kernels, which though they do backport security fixes do not generally provide fixes for other bugs, or any updated drivers.

#38 Re: Intergalactic Communities » Spaced Linux » 2026-10-05 15:20:10

I would suggest that the derivative creators do what they do for very different reasons to someone who maintains packages in a major Linux distribution. If you maintain some obscure Debian/Devuan package and do it well, you won't get the recognition - release your own Linux distro respin however, with it's website, forum / community, where you're the boss, and you'll be surrounded by happy clappers, having your ego stroked. Of course, none of the fans care / know much about the real developers who made all of that possible.

@klein, do you have a source for that? Doesn't sound very positive if that's the case. Obviously it should be bootable in single user mode, set the root password, done. This was the whole problem with the Ubuntu sudo approach, "use it as designed / as we tell you to use it, our way, not yours". This is the kind of controlling behaviour inherent in corporate software or free software developed under corporate influence/funding - i.e. the user is an idiot. All problems start with the user, the user has to be guided, railroaded to doing things our way, controlled, restricted, provided the least possible configuration options, to ensure the "defaults" are mostly preserved.

I'm particularly averse to anything which embraces "flat packs" or similar. Those types of packaging tools come from the mindest that *nix is broken by design and needs Windows style installers. In reality these type of installers are favoured by companies who don't want to deal with multiple packaging formats.

#39 Re: Installation » avoid reinstalling nvidia drivers for every kernel update? » 2026-10-04 11:48:23

To be clear: My post was not a suggestion that the OP get rid of the Nvidia card or a critiisn of Nvidia hardware. Those are simply the options, with getting rid of the hardware in question being the last resort.

I'm on the fence with GPUs. I'm no fan of Nvidia, but Intel and AMD are not exactly saints either. Nvidia have simply refused to expose their proprietary IP and specs to their competitors. Intel and AMD contribute their permissive licensed driver code to the Linux kernel, but the firmware and hardware remains closed, so in effect they have done the same, so not a massive difference there.

#40 Re: Intergalactic Communities » Spaced Linux » 2026-10-04 11:37:05

"Vanity derivatives" also tend to generate technical support requests on the "parent" distributions support channels.

This one in particular seems marketing heavy and a lot of effort seems to have been expended on the website. It appears to have it's own support channel also, so perhaps ask there? (they also accept donations)

Ubuntu started out similarly - someone decided that Debian was boring, "vanilla", needed manual configuration and some willingness on the part of the user to use the command line, plus releases were too far apart, so they set out to make something more appealing to ex Windows users, and of course, they sought to monetise that somehow.

At the time Ubuntu wasn't really much more than a brown theme, a fancy logo, some wallpapers and some other preconfigured defaults. The real difference was in the marketing.

You find the same thing with many of the derivatives these days: Essentially, name it, stick a badge on it and a wallpaper - plus "I'm a nice guy, so I'm going to provide my own preconfigured Linux distro for you, so that you don't have to do it yourself".

#41 Re: Installation » avoid reinstalling nvidia drivers for every kernel update? » 2026-10-04 09:55:07

If you're using the proprietary driver installation shell script from Nvidia's website, then rebuilding the kernel module for every kernel update is the norm.

You have a few options:

- Continue as you are.

- Use the driver from the non-free repository, if the version supports your hardware. This should be automatically rebuilt every kernel update.

- Use the in tree nouveau driver, if it supports your hardware

- Get rid of it; use the Intel or AMD iGPU or source some AMD hardware.

#42 Re: Freedom Hacks » The Absurdist Comedy » 2026-10-01 07:23:27

I am also in agreement.

What you have been witnessing  for the last 20 years or so, is the conflict between the users / hobbyists and lone developers - and the corporations who are now paying for most of it, hiring developers, making donations in return for influence and staffing "foundations" to better control of said projects.

Their business agendas and requirements are often completely at odds with the "UNIX philosophy" of building stuff that works reliably and is modular and simple to configure. Their end product is the opposite to what the tradional user has wanted since day one, hence the aim has been, through deceptive marketing and smears, to paint all of this as "progress" and those who oppose it as luddites. The moves to destroy RMS was by the same people, for the same reasons. For example we didn't hear much about the real benefits of systemd in the early days, we did hear a lot about how sysvinit was "old" and antiquated. Much of this came from corporate mouthpieces, and there were many users who swallowed it and became useful idiots. Some of these even joined the "sysvinit needs replacing" herd and embraced other alternative init systems - simply because they had bought into the "sysvinit is old" propaganda being produced by the systemd backers! Back then the roadmap for systemd was for distributions to abandon sysvinit and "trust" poettering in going ahead with adopting a complex, work in progress, mess, all based on a vague vision or idea. Or that's how it was presented on the surface.

We know that "Big Tech" has very little interest in making anything serviceable or configurable by the user / owner of the device. Big Tech produces locked down, black box stuff which phones home and functions as a surveillance and data mining engine.

Now consider that these very same people are paying for and contributing to Linux, systemd, wayland, Debian, etc. They are the investors in and of course the advocates of LLMs and are pushing code generated by these into the FOSS projects which they control.

Unless someone has the time, money and resources to fork the Linux kernel, the idea of forking everything is a pipe dream.

The BSDs port the Linux DRM/KMS drivers for Intel and AMD, and there is enough work involved there for a team of people.  Any Linux fork would be doing the same and would also be tracking Linux bugs and CVEs. I'm not sure a fork would achieve anything useful and its why others have looked into BSD kernels, but there has been no progress there either. Ultimately much of it is vapour and I have seen a lot of talk and not much else.

Personally I'm in a limbo situation with OS, where I will likely head back to OpenBSD after a 6 year gap...  I see little point in using Linux over Windows (likely as intended) and FreeBSD's slow move towards pkgbase has been something I have been pessimistic about now for a few years. I'm not alone, but as ever the naysayers are being shouted down by its patronising advicates. The way I see, as with the parrots who lined up to accept and promote systemd, they're digging their own graves. The FreeBSD "community" has also deteriorated over the years - that doesn't really seal it for me, but perhaps it's just that extra push, to aid in the decision making

#43 Re: Off-topic » Alternatives to Devuan or ways to make new releases like old releases » 2026-09-28 17:11:26

When I ran Slackware, yes recompiling kernel just became routine. In the end I believe I scripted it to git pull the specific branch i was following, then run the usual make commands and then I would reboot.

The problem is that, unless you settled on an LTS kernel, and it worked for you, you would be recompiling a lot.  The problems with LTS is that they're maintained and supported with the likes of RHEL in mind - so if you encounter driver bugs, for example, which were long since fixed upstream, they won't be fixed in the LTS, as that only needs to serve "enterprise" requirements. I recall fighting with GPU driver problems, then installing a newer kernel
and seeing those problems vanish.

I gave up on Linux over 10 years ago, but if I had to use anything it would probably be Slackware.

#44 Re: Hardware & System Configuration » [SOLVED] tzdata from daedalus-security is a deb12 build on a deb13 system » 2026-09-26 10:07:24

It's not a fork.

Honestly, I think Devuan should just follow Debian's versioning and be done with it.

Less confusion all round.

#45 Re: Off-topic » Alternatives to Devuan or ways to make new releases like old releases » 2026-09-25 07:16:19

I don't see any real issues in building from source and installing under /usr/local

However, I don't believe that's your real problem here. Funny you mentioned Slackware, as that seems to be what you want. I never had any issues with it, but it's horses for courses.

It seems that you want something that always stays much the same  - but switching to that is going to be a bigger learning curve compared to dealing with the new changes / annoyances that will inevitably appear in most Linux distributions over time. With Debian / Devuan, you're only dealing with that roughly every two years. Slackware will give you even more respite, as the last release was about 4 years ago.

This reluctance to change and learn new things is really why Devuan csme about - there were those who disliked and distrusted systemd intensely, but did not want to have to learn to use different package management tools and configuration, so a derivative with systemd removed seemed the best option. I can understand that. Once you're proficient wirh one system, starting from the ground up and relearning everything to do the same things in a different way just seems a waste of time. This is why I have never been a real fan of complex package management syatems - you might become a $LINUX_DISTRO package management expert, but you're working with a layer of abstraction, not the software / OS itself.  Especially with distributions such as Debian where much if it is "automagic", with daemons configured to start and started automatically on installation. If for some reason it breaks, the usual approach is to purge and reinstall, without really understanding what went wrong.

#46 Re: Off-topic » What is software ? » 2026-09-21 07:21:22

Thanks for posting that.

It's a real pity that, apart from a few "conspiracy theorists" like me, that almost no one really cares...

His second note states very bluntly that Intel used his OS as a base to develop an Orwellian "spy engine", to place within every x86 PC.

#47 Re: Off-topic » YouTube-"The UNIX Philosophy: The Rule Modern Linux Forgot" » 2026-09-18 13:10:48

Whether a Linux distribution is "corporate backed" or not, many of the major components which make up the distribution are developed by those on the corporate payroll and / or with corporate funding. This equates to corporate control / influence. The most obvious example being the Linux kernel itself.

"Modern Linux" has moved further and further away from the simple UNIX like approach and towards complexity, including Windows registry style configuration and messy 3rd party package management tools - but that's just the tip of the iceberg. Even if a distribution rejects systemd, it still not immune to the "Modern Linux" mess.

#48 Re: Off-topic » What is software ? » 2026-09-18 07:55:39

Hardware is tangible, software is intangible.

Hardware is physical elecronics: PCBs, ICs, etc.

Software is, when all is said and done, machine code, 1s and 0s.

To get a basic understanding of firmware, read up on EPROMs and EEPROMs. Nowadays "firmware" can be any number of things e.g. the OS of a printer, TV or network adapter flashed on to some kind of EPROM, but really it's still software. The "firmware image" which is flashed to the chip is a binary and thus software.

Historically, firmware was very simple code, often written in assember, to run with limited resources for a very specific taske - nowadays the Intel Management Engine OS for example, which was found to be based on MINIX 3.0 and a typical UEFI are very large and complex.

#49 Re: Desktop and Multimedia » Recurring captcha from Google. » 2026-09-18 07:15:41

Startpage was acquired by System1 (an ad company) via a company it registered for that purpose called "Privacy One".  System1 also acquired Waterfox. Both of these moves sparked some controversy and Waterfox was eventually independent again.

In my view, selling out privacy focused software projects to an ad company was not a smart move - and in the case of startpage, registering a deceptively named company for that purpose, hoping no one would notice, reveals the intent.

#50 Re: Desktop and Multimedia » Recurring captcha from Google. » 2026-09-17 17:21:26

If you use google services, you will always be fighting this kind of thing, unless you allow their scripts, etc.

Your script / ad blocking triggers this and google tries to make it such a pain in the arse that you give up and disable it, to allow their content.

Google are in the advertising / profiling / data mining business. If you use their "free" services, then google want to capture that data. This is why those services are "free".

Board footer

Forum Software