The officially official Devuan Forum!

You are not logged in.

#26 Re: Other Issues » [SOLVED] Excalibur and fail2ban » 2025-08-22 03:27:17

maybe you are getting paid for your efforts.

You have worn out you welcome and good will here

I have posted the information required to solve the OPs problem, because nobody else was doing that. As a result, this thread is now [SOLVED].
What did you contribute here?

#27 Re: Off-topic » Thoughts on Pipewire » 2025-08-22 01:54:14

Resampling is necessary in many run-of-the-mill scenarios. If all you want is to play one stream, that can be done with no resampling. If you want the kind of automagic mixing of multiple inputs and outputs with hotplugged devices over bluetooth and dog knows what else that people tend to expect from a modern system... Some resampling will be happening somewhere.

This is one advantage of pipewire over pulseaudio or ALSA DMIX, it tries quite hard to match your stream to a samplerate your hardware supports, and to never downsample anything if it can be avoided.
Whether or not pipewire's spa resampler is suitable for the cases where it is needed... That's up to your (presumably bat-like) ears to decide.

In general though, unless your resampling algo is really bad (or you're using a SoundBlaster 16), your speakers and listening environment will be doing more to screw up reproduction than anything on the source end.

#28 Re: Installation » [SOLVED] No audio on Excalibur through pipewire on KDE wayland » 2025-08-22 01:29:27

greenjeans wrote:

Not me bro, i'm hanging in there, and I for one appreciate your input. I'm trying man...

You are, and *respect*.

golinux... I would hope you two can come to a place of understanding.

At this point, I doubt it. Maybe when I see go drop some technical solutions to a forum question or code fixes to a broken package, rather than just shouting at other people to do it.
Responding to every problem with "YOU go fix it then", and coming from a position of authority at that... It gets real old, real fast. It sure doesn't achieve anything, or motivate anyone.

The flow of info does seem a bit sparse here of late, but likely that's due to so many changes in this new version, folks have lives outside of Linux and need to make a living still, and a new version of Debian adds a lot more to the load.

The wayland/pipewire thing has been coming down the line for years, we've had plenty of time. Every other non-systemd distro has something in place so it at least *mostly* works, and documentation for issues end-users might encounter.  With Devuan we don't even have a hint of intent or direction, let alone a shipped solution.

#29 Re: Installation » [SOLVED] No audio on Excalibur through pipewire on KDE wayland » 2025-08-22 00:37:18

radiatedradio wrote:

heres the init script, don't just copy it in, change the user name. It works fine for me with KDE, probably would work with any other desktop.

That'll work, but it probably won't play nice with a multi-user/multi-seat system.

The killing processes part could be removed, I just went off of the one I found here.

Killing processes is a dirty hack to kill lingering pipewire processes after a user logs out - which will tie up the sound devices so that they will have no audio if they log in again. Dirty, because it doesn't solve the root problem of making sure pipewire terminates when the launching user logs out (of possibly multiple sessions etc.).

That's one of the things we need real user-services for, this kind of shell-hackery is all well-and-good for a single-user box, but unix/linux is and always has been multi-user. Getting that to work properly means tying the pipewire daemons to the login seat lifecycle somehow, or hacking pipewire to run as a system-wide service (which it absolutely wasn't designed for).

zapper wrote:

As for you going elsewhere, only gotta say, later then, if ever.

I already am "elsewhere". I have exactly one headless box still running Devuan, and if the next upgrade is as much of a disaster as I expect it will be, that one will move to Gentoo as well.

As for being pissed... I'm being told to "go code" by a self-important bureaucrat who can't code, and directed to dead channels to engage with absent devs in non-existent onboarding processes.
And they wonder why anyone who might contribute gives up and goes elsewhere. That airfare to amsterdam go is so proud of? That could have paid someone to start sorting out this mess.

Case in point, let's recap 24 hours of the devuan-dev channel:

Xenguy: LeePen, I can't seem to get any response except crickets around here...
Xenguy: So, you push the keyring.html Live when you want, if and when you want, please.  I'm done with it.
Xenguy: .oO( Like herding cats ... )
golinux: Just updated the pad regarding some upcoming changes. Please have a look and comment before end of day Tuesday

Let's see... No development, one guy giving up because there's nobody around, and golinux dropping some bureaucratic chaff nobody cares about.
And this is right on a major release window. Trixie just dropped, where is everyone?

Why bother? Even the most stalwart rats must be making for the mooring lines by now, with all possible haste. Might as well join them, no?

#30 Re: Other Issues » [SOLVED] Excalibur and fail2ban » 2025-08-21 23:55:23

ralph.ronnquist wrote:

It looks like there you have a task to volunteer for.

You mean giving the forum autoresponder gramophone a whack, because it's stuck again?

zapper wrote:

licensing problem?

There is no "licencing problem". Some APIs were deprecated or moved to external packages, that is all.

zapper wrote:

Asking...

But apparently not reading, because g4sra already explained that.

As usual, a bunch of whinging and finger pointing about "them", "forced" changes, "clusterfuck" upstreams, and a bit of misdirection regarding "awful licence changes"...
While the real problem is right in our back yard, and has nothing to do with any of the favourite punching-bags. Nothing ever changes around here, does it?

#31 Re: Other Issues » [SOLVED] Excalibur and fail2ban » 2025-08-21 09:49:34

Someone needs to port fail2ban to the newer python version

Upstream fail2ban already has compatibility with python 3.13 (inc. bundling the async modules removed with python 3.12), said upstream version (1.1.0) is in trixie, and there appear to be no relevant reports on the Debian BTS...

If you're going to claim "well known and all over the internet", perhaps provide some examples?

Given that the only hits I can get for that exact error are 1: this thread, and 2: an artix user from 5 years ago, and there's no noise about this at all over on FDN, I'm far more inclined to think this has to do with python-systemd and Devuan packaging / shipped configs than anything else.

Ed. Yup, sure enough, again:

$ diff fail2ban_1.0.2-2_all/data/etc/fail2ban/paths-debian.conf fail2ban_1.1.0-8_all/data/etc/fail2ban/paths-debian.conf 
30a31,41
> 
> # In Debian, these services will log to the journal via syslog, so use the
> # journal by default.
> syslog_backend = systemd
> sshd_backend = systemd
> dropbear_backend = systemd
> proftpd_backend = systemd
> pureftpd_backend = systemd
> wuftpd_backend = systemd
> postfix_backend = systemd
> dovecot_backend = systemd

$ diff fail2ban_1.0.2-2_all/data/etc/fail2ban/jail.d/defaults-debian.conf fail2ban_1.1.0-8_all/data/etc/fail2ban/jail.d/defaults-debian.conf
0a1,4
> [DEFAULT]
> banaction = nftables
> banaction_allports = nftables[type=allports]
> 
1a6,7
> backend = systemd
> journalmatch = _SYSTEMD_UNIT=ssh.service + _COMM=sshd

That's not going to work, now is it? Nice job Devuan packaging team merging stuff from debian without testing it bot, great catch. Definitely fixing all the systemd things for this premiere systemd-free distro. roll

@OP, make sure all your jails are using the 'polling', 'pyinotify' (if you have that installed) or 'auto' backends. This might not be your problem, but I suspect it is based on where that error appears to be coming from...
Either way though: Blindingly obvious excalibur packaging fail. If it doesn't cause problems here, it will later.

#32 Re: Installation » [SOLVED] No audio on Excalibur through pipewire on KDE wayland » 2025-08-21 05:13:20

Perhaps that task has been waiting for YOU to suggest it, set it up and keep track of all its moving parts.

Keep repeating the same bullshit Go, maybe it will come true. Or just go back to your CSS and conferences.
The dev channel is utterly dead, forum questions get canned responses, nothing ever changes. I'm done here.
This right here is why you have no new devs. If you can't figure that out, you have my sympathy... But not my motivation or any of my time. I'll spend those on a distro where somebody gives a fuck.

different aspects of devuan's development

How many aspects can *crickets* and that one dude giving up because *crickets* have?

#33 Re: Installation » [SOLVED] No audio on Excalibur through pipewire on KDE wayland » 2025-08-21 02:44:50

So, IOW "There is no formal procedure to become a Devuan contributor."

Why do I even bother. Guess I'll go see if #devuan-dev is still a whole bunch of resounding silence.

zapper . . . do you ever have anything useful to say?

Good to know I'm not the only one who has noticed. roll

derailed

The answer(s) to the original question and comments on the situation in general have been covered ad-nauseam in another thread, what else is there to do?

#34 Re: Installation » [SOLVED] No audio on Excalibur through pipewire on KDE wayland » 2025-08-21 02:06:50

Sigh...

steve_v wrote:

Four months ago I asked:

What I would like to know is: Which way does Devuan intend to handle this, and is there anything that needs doing there? What solutions are being considered? I contributed one possibility way upthread, is it worth persevering with or is Devuan going to do something totally different?
Is anything at all happening, or are we just going to do the "wait for debian to make a move, then delay release for 3 months while we put out fires" thing again?

And I still don't have an answer.

Passive-agressive response still fails to answer question.

steve_v wrote:

mentorship program... documented pathway... active developers in the user IRC channel
Where is any of this stuff for Devuan?

Or other question for that matter.

Is it any wonder I said "fsck it then", and moved over to Gentoo? Why would I care? The horse is at the water, but it's not drinking.

Perhaps you might consider contributing

Perhaps, if it's less painfull than pulling proverbial teeth. Are you on the Recruiters Team? Where is the IRC channel to find a mentor and who should I ask? Are there tests I would need to take? Where do I find documentation on this process?
Does this project actually have an organised development process, or is it just a collection of random personal-project warts on Debian's backside?

You want contributors? Make it easy, make it organised. "Why don't YOU $whatever" is pointless if you don't also set out what, how, and who to contact.

#35 Re: Installation » [SOLVED] No audio on Excalibur through pipewire on KDE wayland » 2025-08-21 01:47:39

getting pissed

I've been pissed with this whole situation for some time, because nothing at all appears to be happening, and the standard tag-line around here when it comes to systemd-dependent packages is "just don't use them"... While the distro steadily looses functionality and the users steadily loose options.
Systemd is not going to go away, and burying our heads in the sand isn't going to fix anything.
User-units are a thing, and we need a solution. Define what that solution should look like and someone might just provide it.

EDX-0 dreamed up a whole user-init system, is Devuan interested? Is this the solution we should be contributing to? Who knows, there's nothing but silence from leadership.

Need more devs? Sure, every project needs more devs. You don't get more devs by bitching about it, you get them by training up more devs.
That means setting out what needs doing, how to go about doing it, and how to get it into the distro, then providing hands-on guidance and mentoring to make sure it doesn't break anything.

I have never written code and I couldn't write a bash script if my life depended on it

And yet, here you are shouting at others for not doing those things.

Dyne only provided airfare to the Amsterdam Conference to two people and I was one of them.

Yes yes, I'm sure you're very important. We were talking about "sanitizing" packages, were we not? What do airfares have to do with that?

#36 Re: Installation » [SOLVED] No audio on Excalibur through pipewire on KDE wayland » 2025-08-21 01:17:35

Ahh yes, Mr. Pot turns up to shout at Mr. Kettle, right on queue.

how many packages have YOU offered to "sanitize'

Right back at you^. I don't see any code or package contributions at all in your history on git.devuan.org...

in the trenches

... Twiddling with documentation, web-infra and theming. Not fixing broken packages or implementing solutions for systemd-dependent components.

Four months ago I asked:

What I would like to know is: Which way does Devuan intend to handle this, and is there anything that needs doing there? What solutions are being considered? I contributed one possibility way upthread, is it worth persevering with or is Devuan going to do something totally different?
Is anything at all happening, or are we just going to do the "wait for debian to make a move, then delay release for 3 months while we put out fires" thing again?

And I still don't have an answer. How do you expect "users to step up" when there is nothing but radio-silence from the supposed leadership?

To take Gentoo as an example: There's an established mentorship program and a well documented pathway to moving from "random packages in user overlay" to "peer-reviewed packages in guru" to "dev reviewed packages in official repo" to "dev comitting directly to official repo".
There's a whole set of documentation and guidelines on the subject, and right from the beginning there are active developers in the user IRC channel when we have random questions. Hell, asking there often gets official packages fixed in minutes.
Where is any of this stuff for Devuan?

#37 Re: Installation » [SOLVED] No audio on Excalibur through pipewire on KDE wayland » 2025-08-21 00:20:58

A solution I found, which i haven't tried yet, is that gentoo ships a pipewire launcher service file in their distro for openRC, which I'm using.

gentoo-pipewire-launcher is intended to be started per-user as part of session startup (e.g. xdg-autostart or xinitrc), not by openrc.
As I said above, pipewire is intended to be started by systemd user units for each user login, not system-wide by init as root. Current openrc releases do have (experimental) user-unit support which could handle this... But this is Devuan we're talking about here so good luck finding current anything in the repos.

To quote the Gentoo wiki page (which you should also read completely):

There is no truly standardized way (outside of systemd) to load PipeWire when starting a graphical shell, and users need to choose the correct approach based on how their graphical environment is started.

In all cases where systemd user services are not being used, PipeWire must be started before anything that might try to connect to any sound input or output, such as a volume monitoring applet.

Using the gentoo script is one option, others are discussed in the thread I linked earlier. How you actually launch any of those depends on your graphical session, for KDE on wayland, xdg-autostart is probably easiest.

FWIW, this was my suggestion, and is what I'm using right now on Gentoo (It works well enough I haven't gotten around to moving it over to openrc user-units). Make of it what you will, it does require backporting a not-ancient daemon version from unstable.

I also wouldn't have to deal with this if by default when I install KDE with the whole distro, I didn't get a broken sound server, and having to manually switch to pulse.

Indeed. While it is likely a dead horse, I'll flog it some more here: Devuan, as a supposed leader in systemd-free distros... Does precious little leading.
Where real work is needed to get things working without systemd, solutions are lifted from Gentoo (eudev, elogind, opentmpfiles etc.). Everything else is just banning packages rather than fixing them, or shipping broken setups like we see here with wayland and pipewire.
I have asked repeatedly what Devuan's direction and preferred solution for user-units is, and all I get is a bunch of "nothing, wait for Debian to fix it" wilful inaction.

#38 Re: Installation » [SOLVED] No audio on Excalibur through pipewire on KDE wayland » 2025-08-20 06:23:41

its supposed to be started with whatever init is chosen (bopenrc/sysvinit/runit/s6)

No, it (all 3 daemons, in the right order) is supposed to be started as systemd user-units, with dependency management and supervision. Most distros without systemd ship a variety of (usually shell) hacks to do the same, with varying degrees of reliability...
Devuan ships nothing, and just leaves the mess for the end-user to figure out.

I think that is what steve_v means.

It is not.

how I start alsa

You don't "start" alsa, alsa is kernel drivers and doesn't include any daemons to start. Do you actually have any idea what you are talking about?

I imagine it works similarly for pipewire

Imagination does nothing toward Devuan shipping a pipewire package that works out of the box, or solving the OP's problem.

All of this has been discussed thoroughly in the thread I linked above, why are you "imagining" instead of reading that?

#39 Re: Installation » [SOLVED] No audio on Excalibur through pipewire on KDE wayland » 2025-08-19 23:41:01

radiatedradio wrote:

running pipewire manually through my terminal

That's not how pipewire is meant to be started.

radiatedradio wrote:

sudo /usr/bin/pipewire

That's not even remotely how pipewire is meant to be started.

radiatedradio wrote:

What could be the issue?

Failure to read the documentation or search the forum.

greenjeans wrote:

do you have Pipewire installed

They do, but they're starting only one part of it, manually, and with sudo for maximum borkage (sudo is always the answer roll). It can't find it's runtime directory, because that env is not set for root (even if sudo propagated those vars, which it doesn't).
Even if it could, sound still won't work without wireplumber (and pipewire-pulse if you want the KDE mixer and stuff).

#40 Re: Hardware & System Configuration » [SOLVED] liquorix kernel on excalibur » 2025-08-19 22:34:00

Personally I'd prefer no out-of-tree drivers be included by default at all, but given how lazy some users are these days (note the celebration when images with non-free enabled by default were released, because apparently installing nvidia-kernel-dkms is hard), I can see why they do this.

The alternative to removing the package is using dkms to exclude it from being built for whichever $kernel_version is problematic - i.e. dkms remove [module] [-k kernel/arch]. The drawback is that you need to remember you did that, and remember to do it again when your shiny-new kernel is updated.
Better, just backport drivers that work as I mentioned earlier. It takes 5 minutes.

In this case though, you don't need tp-smapi unless you have a thinkpad, and one of a limited set of models at that... Debian with the kitchen-sink thing again. roll

#41 Re: Hardware & System Configuration » [SOLVED] liquorix kernel on excalibur » 2025-08-19 19:37:19

Maybe it's possible to disable the build of 'tp_smapi'.

Well it's an out-of-tree DKMS module, so yeah, obviously, if you don't need it just remove the package.
I assumed that since you had it installed, you wanted it.

the next liquorix kernel

... Will have exactly the same problem. That's what I said above: Kernel packages and DKMS packages need to be in sync, so if you run a newer kernel you need to backport newer versions of any additional drivers as well.

kernel-hacking

This is not "kernel hacking", it's Debian packaging 102 and the usual stuff you need to be aware of if you deviate from the stable release or add non-devuan packages.

#42 Re: Hardware & System Configuration » [SOLVED] liquorix kernel on excalibur » 2025-08-18 05:07:49

Entering directory '/var/lib/dkms/tp_smapi/0.44/build'
...
error: implicit declaration of function ‘del_timer_sync’ [-Wimplicit-function-declaration]

That's nothing to do with liquorix specifically, the tp_smapi driver version you are trying to build is using an obsolete function name and will break with any kernel >6.14, because:
https://github.com/torvalds/linux/commi … 5ec856c916

This is fixed in tp_smapi v0.45, which is in unstable. If you want to run a kernel newer than the de[bi|vu]an release you're tracking ships, expect that you will need to backport any dkms modules as well.
The process is not particularly complicated, but it is manual work. Do not be lazy and just add the unstable repos to sources.list, without very careful per-package pins this will bork things sooner or later.

#44 Re: Installation » how to fix broken dep hell? » 2025-08-16 16:30:43

deepforest wrote:

Devuan Ceres

Sure it is lol

Those conflicting packages appear to be from stable and unstable, respectively... So you have an incomplete dist-upgrade you need to finish, or you tried upgrading from stable to unstable directly (which is unsupported), or you have created a franken[debi/devu]an (again) by enabling sources for multiple releases.

All of the those are liable to break apt in fun ways, but you don't listen when people tell you why things like this are a bad idea, so, uhh, enjoy?

deepforest wrote:

how to fix broken dep hell?

1: Pin your target release at priority 1001.
2: Dist-upgrade and --fix-broken, see if it works. If it doesn't (it probably won't), try aptitude's solver first, then resolve remaining conflicts manually (directly with dpkg if needs be).
3: Remove any remaining installed packages from any other release, and any mention of other releases from sources.list.
4: Dist-upgrade and autoremove.
5: Remove your pin.
6: Hope you found all the mess, so it doesn't bite you again later.

#45 Re: Hardware & System Configuration » [SOLVED] Devuan 6 excalibur, OpenRC, networking, /etc/hosts ingnored » 2025-08-14 13:16:53

Well for one,

172.22.22.05	colossus.home colossus

"172.22.22.05" isn't a correctly formatted IP address...
And for two,

getent hosts

would have made it fairly obvious whether or not your /etc/hosts file was the problem, since it returns only valid entries.

$ printf '%s\n' "* File:"; cat /etc/hosts; printf '%s\n' "* Reality:"; getent hosts
* File:
127.0.0.1 localhost damnation.lan damnation

# The following lines are desirable for IPv6 capable hosts
::1     ip6-localhost ip6-loopback
fe00::0 ip6-localnet
ff00::0 ip6-mcastprefix
ff02::1 ip6-allnodes
ff02::2 ip6-allrouters
172.22.22.05    colossus.home colossus

* Reality:
127.0.0.1       localhost damnation.lan damnation
127.0.0.1       ip6-localhost ip6-loopback
$ printf '%s\n' "* File:"; cat /etc/hosts; printf '%s\n' "* Reality:"; getent hosts
* File:
127.0.0.1 localhost damnation.lan damnation

# The following lines are desirable for IPv6 capable hosts
::1     ip6-localhost ip6-loopback
fe00::0 ip6-localnet
ff00::0 ip6-mcastprefix
ff02::1 ip6-allnodes
ff02::2 ip6-allrouters
172.22.22.5     colossus.home colossus

* Reality:
127.0.0.1       localhost damnation.lan damnation
127.0.0.1       ip6-localhost ip6-loopback
172.22.22.5     colossus.home colossus

As I said, networkmangler is a red herring and it was only brought up because everyone here loves to hate on it.
I mean I kinda hate it too, but going straight to "Damn new software, the old ways were better, life was simpler, bloody clouds etc. etc." before even trying to investigate the problem is plain ridiculous.

#46 Re: Other Issues » Mozilla and LLMs » 2025-08-13 11:52:07

You mean everyone hasn't been setting 'browser.ml.enable == false' since this garbage first rolled out? The mind boggles.

#47 Re: Hardware & System Configuration » [SOLVED] Devuan 6 excalibur, OpenRC, networking, /etc/hosts ingnored » 2025-08-13 11:32:19

Altoid wrote:

got tired of seeing my /etc/resolv.conf continually being tampered with...
disabled the crap Network Manager...
whose bloody $%& workstation is it?

rolfie wrote:

NetworkManager WILL affect the /etc/resolv.conf and take it out of the loop. Thats why I omit using NetworkManager

FFS people, get a grip. Networkmangler will mangle /etc/resolv.conf if it is configured to do so. You can shout about it, you can remove it... Or you could just do a 10 second search and set it up to do what you want.

Andre4freedom wrote:

remove the network manager. That's okay for a workstation PC, but NOT for a laptop.

Indeed. While there are many other ways to configure networking on a mobile device, networkmangler + modemmangler + [all the 50 plugins] does make a certain amount of sense.
Unfortunately, the prevailing attitude here seems to be shouting "[x] is crap, I hate [x], why does this new complicated [x] exist" rather than addressing the question in a sensible manner.

#48 Re: Other Issues » Stardict - possibly problematic application? » 2025-08-09 06:34:52

Yeah, this is pretty much expected behaviour given the purpose of that plugin. Auto-translating the X11 primary selection is a little unusual, but  understandable if the intent is to provide live translation in a tooltip.
The only real problem I see here is that this behaviour doesn't appear to be mentioned in the project documentation... But then the website is a mess and I only read English, so it's entirely possible I just missed it.

In any case, this is a clipboard-monitoring online auto-translation tool sending clipboard content to a translation service. So what? How else would it work, magic?
If anyone is actually concerned, consider this a wakeup to exercise some garden-variety due-diligence with the software you run. The source code is right there in plain sight.

All the noise here is really because it's using the "insecure" X clipboard functionality (which must be demonised wherever possible), and the servers in question are in China (which is the current political boogeyman). Boring, predictable, yawn, etc.

#49 Re: Off-topic » For those who like parody... » 2025-08-07 05:51:11

harsh as usual I see

Oh, I see how it is.
People whose politics don't align with yours or you otherwise disagree with are "assholes", "parasites" or "facists", and saying so is fine... But calling out shallow clickbait for what it is is "harsh", because you agree with the the creator's views generally.

You want to play in the "Linux news videos" corner of the interwebs, you'll find the vast majority of it is regurgitated, rehashed nonsense from other sources.
Lunduke's videos are him reading his own blog posts about things he read on other blog posts, Brodie's are him making excited faces and waving his hands around while reading release announcements or clicking around other people's websites. Neither are particularly interesting, nor particularly creative.

As for muppets, you have seen Brodie's video thumbnails, right? I mean, if you go out of your way to pose like one...

rust not being a magical bullet

Of course it isn't, and anyone with a clue about programming knows it without watching some random not-very-technical video.
Rust is a tool like any other language, what you do with it is up to you, and using it doesn't magically make your code good (though it does make it harder to write particular kinds of bad).

#50 Re: Off-topic » For those who like parody... » 2025-08-07 05:04:32

he is making fun of GNOME developers silly

No shit, Sherlock.
The guy is still a muppet, and his videos are still all shallow clickbait devoid of any interesting technical merit. They range from "look, controversy" to "shiny new thing released"... Both kinds of "news" I can get elsewhere without the hype and hyperbole.

Given your signature I would have thought you would understand after watching it

It's blindingly obvious what he's getting at from the title, no need to watch it.
I'll go out on a limb and guess that this is just a "reaction video" clicking through some website he found, the "joke" probably isn't even his... As usual.

Board footer

Forum Software