You are not logged in.
.. while current MATE upstream is all gtk3.
Yeah I was looking at that, and various bits of functionality are being thrown out in Mate just like the final days of gnome2. Some GTK/gnome apps I have always liked are doing the same, Exaile has been my music player and internet radio player for years, but latest version is all GTK3.
I am starting to think GTK needs a fork as well. The Gnome/RH/systemd crowd are calling the shots when it comes to GTK3 development, and we all know where that trainwreck leads.
I usually just delete anything that gives me crap like that.
There are no errors, just cruft that hasn't been RM'ed yet.
![]()
I think it is 'designed' to be faulty, so that RH can sell you a support contract/package & make money out of Linux.
Well that is the Microsoft system for success, just look at the AWESOME and ginormous support/antivirus/repair industry they spawned. ![]()
You can really see the commercialism shine when they wax poetic about "branding" and removing configuration options so all the dumb people will finally HAVE TO DO IT THEIR WAY WHICH IS OF COURSE THE RIGHT WAY!
If you want an alternate shutdown system, I have tested Obsession extensively in both Openbox and Mate and it works great. Super easy to make keyboard shortcuts using obsession and get one click shutdown, suspend, hibernate etc.
*edit* testing
or analog stereo via RCA from HDMI device.
Well that part is simple and should work fine with alsa, if your speaker/receiver setup takes a conventional RCA input, just make or buy a patch cable and use the headphone output from your computer.
Yes, screensaver made sense back when it saved a CRT from phosphor burnout. Generally obsoleted by modern screen tech.
Now I only use one to keep a screen active.
Agree completely. No point these days really, I disable the service on startup in my Mate partitions. In openbox I just never install one.
If you just want a screenlocker, i3lock works great.
One nice thing about using lower-spec systems is the revelation of poor practices.
^This +100
Exactly why I do any development stuff on the lowest spec machine I have, it finds all the hidden flaws. And if you can make something run good on a real entry-level machine, it'll work great on better spec stuff.
Updating this as I have now tried and tested a fair bit in openbox, and can confirm the slowdown there too, though it's not as bad as the complete freeze-ups in mate. Whereas normally my openbox menu opens immediately, there's now a 2-3 second delay.
Deleting the scalable (SVG) icons completely fixes the problem again.
Small SVG's like Devuan uses are not a problem, it's the sometimes 1-2 mb ones in Libre that become a problem.
Handbrake is still the king though, with it's mighty 3.4 mb SVG icon, they get their icon replaced with the monkeyface-icon-of-shame for that.
Hexchat here, works great, easy interface.
Well done VUA's one and all!!! And THANK YOU!
![]()
@greenjeans: At this point we've hijacked this thread
Nevertheless, I think I can help with your issue because I'm also a keyboard guy...
I have a ton of custom keybindings and they're essential to how I use my computer. I use xbindkeys instead of MATE's builtin "Keyboard Shortcuts" because I like to keep my keybindings in alphabetical order in a text file that I can easily edit (namely ~/.xbindkeysrc). With xbindkeys all my keybindings work in Devuan MATE, even if desktop is empty. I never have to click anywhere.
Just install xbindkeys, make sure that it autostarts (it should automatically take care of this for you--take a peek in Startup Applications after installing xbindkeys), and create ~/.xbindkeysrc with your keybindings. Here's a snippet from my ~/.xbindkeysrc to give you the idea (Mod4 is my GNU key, formerly known as Windows key):
"mate-terminal" Mod4+t "thunderbird" Control+Alt+tAny time you update the file, xbindkeys needs to be restarted in order for changes to take effect. Enjoy!
Thanks for that! Will keep in mind as that looks like a very sane and simple way of doing keybindings.
Figured out the Mate issue though, always something simple....I had forgotten to check and re-do the conky settings when I migrated the build from openbox to mate, conky will work almost universally regardless of how you set it, but working-without-conflicting with Mate takes some specific settings. Need to set it to draw it's own window, and the own_window_type needs to be "override".
Another project is a new menu for openbox (also in Gtk), dynamic and multilingual. Here you are a video:
http://gnuinos.org/openbox-menu1.mpg
This menu will have also a static header (still not included), containing items like "gmrun", "terminal", "web-browser", etc... and a static footer, containig as a final item the "Exit" option (at the same developed in gtk, i.e. a new openbox-logout).
Sounds exactly like obmenu-generator, check out Miyolinux, it already uses it and it's what i'm using in Vuu-do openbox.
greenjeans wrote:The QT in VLC aggravates me too, unfortunately the other bad thing about VLC is that it has become almost the only game in town. Everything just always works, and that's a great comfort to someone trying to make a user-friendly system.
The QT VLC did not work for me when it was first installed on jessie. I ended up snatching the GTK version from Wheezy which works just fine. Of course that's a very short term solution . . .
Interesting, was that using Xfce?
Worked fine for me on Mate. It doesn't take all the QT libraries to run, just a few, I just hate having any QT at all on my pristine GTK system.
I agree 100% about Libreoffice, that should be left to the user to choose to install or not, it's been my experience that ~95% of end-users never use it.
The QT in VLC aggravates me too, unfortunately the other bad thing about VLC is that it has become almost the only game in town. Everything just always works, and that's a great comfort to someone trying to make a user-friendly system.
MPV needs a little work, I can't seem to get it to play DVD's on openbox, and doing it in mate took some work. Needs moar gui.
I like Exaile for music, works really well for me, internet radio works great with lots of stations pre-programmed in now, you can even add "now playing" info from Exaile into a conky display.
Some of mine are even spins of spins. ![]()
Devuan has been incredibly stable under most conditions for the last 7-8 months that i've used it, despite the Beta and now RC status, works great for rolling your own distro already, but then my understanding was that this was always one of the main goals of Devuan, to be a base distro to work off of. The devs are very encouraging about it, and there's a lot of support for folks who are trying to do so. Lots of good tools being developed to automate the process, but I expect everyone does it slightly different.
I do mine by de-construction first, then rebuild and use Refracta-tools to make installable hybrid iso's.
You can also try out the new live-sdk, some are using that, i've tried it and it's next on my list of things i'd like to learn better.
Well i'm not the ninja here obviously, but wondering if maybe you need to run update-initramfs -u?
I would think that would occur as part of the process after installing a new kernel but I could be wrong, thus my suggestion.
This just literally made what was a darned frustrating day (chasing a bug I made myself somehow), into me being a happy camper, thanks Golinux!!
Okay, guess I better get back to the drawing board since I made the list and all. ![]()
well now i've got a real doozy going because of all this, lol.
I have set a bunch of custom keybindings in the new mate build as I mentioned above, and they work fine, as long as you left-click the mouse on the empty desktop in between trying to use them.
It's not like that on my other mate install, so i know it's not mate that's broken. It's not like that on the openbox Vuu-do build that I used as a base for this build either.
If you have any windows open at all, the keyboard shortcuts all work fine no matter how many times you use the keypress-combos, but as soon as you close all windows, you will again need to left-click on the desktop before you can use one, and in between every attempt at using them.
Some package or such i'm missing maybe, as I built this mate a piece at a time with just base packages, no meta-packages or tasks.
Seems like it won't re-focus on the desktop after you use and close a keyboard-shortcut or a window.
arrgh, literally the last thing I have to fix before running what should be a nice Vuu-do-mate edition alpha iso, but it's been all day and part of last night and i'm still stuck. ![]()
@afuerst: Haha, I know what you mean. My wife is still on Debian Jessie MATE and has the same expectation (lid closed = "off").
Since I prefer nothing to happen when my lid is closed, I didn't even realize that this option is currently missing from Devuan+MATE. Indeed, in mate-power-preferences I cannot find the option to suspend when lid is closed.
See i'm the same way when it comes to suspend and hibernate, have never used either one in my life, so wasn't aware of the options disappearing in mate-power-manager and the shutdown dialog.
I do remember seeing issues with both going back a long time ago.
As i'm watching Mate develop (or not) i'm starting to see options for configuration and such go bye-bye just like they did in gnome 2 the last couple years as they were destroying it to make way for that gnome 3 junk.
Not real stoked going forward like that, doesn't seem in keeping with 'nix philosophy. I took a peak at 1.16. in ascii and options for custom colors for a given theme via the gui is gone apparently. You can still edit the theme itself directly I guess, but that seems like a crappy thing to do to new users who like to experiment with colors, it was a good feature.
I assume this is an option to initiate the suspend? More beautiful than sending the dbus-command, but still this would need a regularly running cronjob (which I would prefer to avoid).
I should have been clearer, this doesn't address the laptop-close-lid issue in xfce4-power-manager.
It's just an option for adding simple quick suspend/hibernate/reboot/shutdown (on-demand) options via keyboard shortcuts, and the conky display which I use anyway is just a good place to have them visible for easy reference.
Obsession works pretty good for this, I added some custom keyboard-shortcuts and added them to the conky display on my system so they are always handy.
/usr/bin/obsession-exit -s (suspend)
-H (hibernate)
-r (reboot)
-p (power-off/shutdown)
I think they are in the experimental repo, also can be found at Refracta sourceforge.
Try this in your sources.list file:
deb http://packages.devuan.org/devuan/ experimental maingolinux wrote:The showstopper is Mate not Devuan.
I don't want to fingerpoint anyone (you could also argument Debian is the showstopper because of making systemd the default init system) - I just need a solution so I can migrate the main laptop to Devuan. AFAIK I have to switch to Devuan as long as I am using jessie, there won't be a migration path from stretch (and I have a feeling why this would be too much effort).
I'm actually working on that right now, as i'm building a mate mini at the moment.
First part of workaround: Uninstall mate-power-manager and mate-power-manager-common. Install xfce4-power-manager and it's dependencies, make sure you have libupower-glib3 installed before you try to install xfce-power-manager, it's a dependency but for some reason may not be tagged as such.
Everything works in xfce power manager for me except for : options when I close lid of laptop
Other than that, everything else works, suspend, hibernate, what to do when power button is pushed etc.
For the second part i'm trying to figure out how to substitute a command in the main mate menu, the package "obsession" normally used for Openbox shutdown, also works in mate and offers suspend and hibernate and all other shutdown options you'd expect. I can click the obsession-logout file in /usr/bin/ and it pops up the shutdown menu just fine, just need to make it work in the main mate menu. (Obviously you can stick a .desktop file in the menu somewhere or in the panel and use it in the meantime, I just want to integrate it in to a mate install fully).
Afuerst: This has been a bug on and off for literally years, apparently there is an on-again off-again issue with upower and mate-power-manager.
I also have a post in the issues section about the other bug this causes, failure to properly poll battery status and wrong systray icons as a result.
Devuan is using an OLD version of upower, maybe a conflict with systemd is preventing use of a newer version. Newer upower has dropped support of hibernation among other things, but since this old-as-hell version doesn't work either, not sure what to do at this point.
XFCE had some issues with it too, but looks like they changed the code in their power manager, which is what Mate should do too.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+sour … ug/1419321
https://bugs.archlinux.org/task/40031